Are you eager to boost your website's performance on search engines like Google but unsure where to start or what truly makes a difference in SEO?
Then "SEO Is Not That Hard" hosted by Edd Dawson, a seasoned expert with over 20 years of experience in building and successfully ranking websites, is for you.
Edd shares actionable tips, proven strategies, and valuable insights to help you improve your Google rankings and create better websites for your users.
Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned SEO professional, this podcast offers something for everyone. Join us as we simplify SEO and give you the knowledge and skills to achieve your online goals with confidence.
You’ve been told SEO is dead and GEO (Generative Engine Optimisation) has replaced it. New discipline, new rules, and often a new retainer. Eds doesn’t buy it, but in this episode he takes the other side seriously.
Edd works through the six strongest arguments that GEO is a different thing, gives the best version of each, and explains where he thinks it falls down. He also concedes the two points where the other side is right, and finishes with three things to do differently on Monday.
One of those three is something almost nobody is doing: checking what AI crawlers are doing on your site. Salience.com shows you which pages they’re reading and which they never touch, with no tracking script to add. Find out more at salience.com.
Agree or disagree? Get in touch and tell Edd.
SEO Is Not That Hard is hosted by Edd Dawson and brought to you by KeywordsPeopleUse.com
To get a personal no-obligation demo of how KeywordsPeopleUse could help you boost your SEO and get a 7 day FREE trial of our Standard Plan book a demo with me now
Hello, and welcome back to SEO Is Not That Hard. It's me here, Ed Dawson, as always, and today we're gonna talk about GEO versus SEO. What are they? What's the difference? Is there a difference? So if you've been on LinkedIn at any point over the last year, you'll have been told that SEO is dead, and it's been replaced by GEO, which stands for Generative Engine Optimization. New discipline, new rules, and I think in a lot of cases, people trying to charge a new retainer for it. Now, I don't buy it, and today I'm gonna tell you why. But I'm also gonna do something that it's just SEO crowd rarely do, and that's I'm gonna take the other side seriously. There are six real arguments that I can see that GEO is a different thing, and a couple of them are good. So I'm gonna give you the best version of each one and then tell you where I think it falls down. So my position up front, I believe GEO is, in the main, SEO with a new scoreboard and a wider pitch. The game underneath hasn't changed.
What's changed is where you look to find out whether you're winning So if we strip SEO back to first principles, it comes down to four questions. One, discoverabili-discoverability. So can the system find out that your page exists at all? That's things like links, sitemaps, mentions elsewhere on the web. Secondly, crawlability. Once you know the page is there, can it actually fetch it, or is it hitting a block, a timeout, or a wall of JavaScript? Thirdly, indexability. Having fetched it, can the system store it and pull it back out later? Is it the canonical version? Is it worth keeping? That kind of thing. Fourth, understandability. Does the system know what the page is about, who it's from, and whether to trust it? Now swap the word Google for ChatGPT or Claude or Perplexity. In every one of these sentences, nothing breaks. An AI assistant that searches the web still has to find your page, it still has to fetch it, it still has to retrieve it from an index, and it still has to make sense of it before it can cite you. There is no secret fifth step. So when someone tells me GEO is a completely different discipline, my question is simple: which of those four has been replaced? And so far, I haven't heard a good answer to that yet. What I have had is six objections, so let's go through them one by one. But before the objections, I should say, here's the biggest piece of evidence on my side.
Around the 15th of May this year, Google published its first ever official guide to optimizing for AI search, and it answered this exact question. From Google's point of view, optimizing for AI Overviews and AI Mode is the same as optimizing for search. AEO and GEO are, in their framing, still SEO. And they went further, and they named some of the tactics that you could ignore as far as Google's concerned. Things like chopping your content into tiny chunks, special AI-only schema, rewriting your pages for AI, all of that. None of it is needed as far as they're concerned. Now, I could stop the episode here and say that's it. That's the win. But that would be cheating, and here's why. That's because Google here is marking its own homework. That guidance covers Google's products. It says nothing about ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, or Copilot. And Google has an obvious interest in telling you to do the things you already do for Google is the real thing you should keep doing. So Google's guide gets me part of the way. To get the rest of the way, we have to deal with the objections properly.
objection one, Google only speaks for Google. The best version of this argument goes like this. Every AI engine has its own crawler, its own index or search partner, and its own way of choosing sources. None of them has put out an it's just SEO statement. So being good at Google tells you nothing about being good at the rest. And it's true that the indexes differ, but look at what you'd actually do about it. You'd make sure that the crawlers can reach you, you'd make sure your pages are fetchable and readable, and you make sure whichever index they pull f- pull from, you're in it. That's the same four fundamentals pointed at more systems. More places to be found is not a new discipline. When Bing launched, nobody invented Bing engine optimization and SEO, search engine optimization, was a thing before Google. Okay? Google was just another search engine. SEO came mainly all about Google because of Google's domination of classic search. Now we have new areas of search, doesn't mean that this isn't SEO. Objection
two, ranking no longer predicts citation. This is probably the strongest one, so let's talk about it a bit more. So in mid two thousand and twenty-five, Ahrefs found that about three-quarters of the pages cited in Google's AI Overviews also ranked in the top ten for that same search. And when they rerun the study later this this year in twenty twenty-six, it was down to thirty-eight percent. And Bright Edge, using different data, put it even lower at nearer seventeen percent. Now, for the standalone system, assistance, it's lower still. Ahrefs looked at ChatGPT, Gemini, and Copilot and found that only twelve percent of links they cite in Google's top ten for the same prompt. So their argument is, if you can rank first and not be cited and be cited without ranking, these are clearly different games. But there's actually an explanation for this And it's called query fanout. The AI, when you ask it a question, doesn't just search for your prompt. What it does is it breaks your question into a set of smaller related searches, runs all of them, and then cites the pages that keep turning up. So the cited page's ranking is just ranking for searches you didn't think to track. That doesn't mean rankings stopped mattering. It means tracking one keyword at a time was measuring the wrong thing. And the fix is to do what I've been saying for years on this podcast, and that's to properly cover a topic, properly answer all the follow-up questions people might have. Go in depth with your content This is what all good SEOs have been saying for more than a decade. This is topical authority all over So the key thing here is it's still about having good content on your site that covers your topic properly So let's move on to objection three: it's a mention, not a click. Now,
the argument here is that SEO earns you a visit and GEO earns you a name check inside someone else's answer, often with no visit at all. Different outcome, different job, is what people say. But we've been here before, and always have been here for quite a while with Google, and that is things like featured snippets, knowledge panels, people also ask. Zero-click search has been talked about in SEO for years. It's been a problem we've dealt with for years, but we didn't rename the entire industry over it. The goal of SEO has never been only just the click. It's about being the answer in the place people are looking. What's changed is how you prove the value of that, and that's a reporting problem, which is exactly the kind of thing that I'm trying to get across here. Objection four: the work has moved off your website. This one says that the AI answers lean heavily on third parties, Reddit threads, review sites, YouTube, comparison pages, press coverage, that kind of thing. Your own site is necessary but no longer enough. So the work is now PR and community, and that's a different team with a different budget. And I'd just call that off-page SEO. Digital PR, reviews, being talked about in the right places, describing yourself consistently everywhere, none of that is new. Look at the podcast history o-of this podcast. We've been talking about all those things for the past three years and, but with n-no point ever relating back to just being an AI search thing. This is classic outreach. It is SEO. It's not technical SEO, but it's part of the SEO toolkit The only thing that I might concede here is possibly the weighting. The currency is shifting away from links and towards mentions, and brand matters more than it did, I would say. But that's just a change of emphasis inside the discipline. And we've had this happen before when mobile was an afterthought and it became the default and everything had to be mobile-ready, and we still called it SEO Objection five: visibility is now probabilistic Ask an AI the same question twice, and you can get different sources each time and a slightly different answer, different text.
Success is now a share of voice across hundreds of prompts, not a fixed ranking. And this is the objection I actually agree with the most. And if you notice what the difference is, it's a difference in how you measure, not in what you do. And I'd also say, actually, going back, rankings were never as fixed as traditional ranking reports in classic search made them look like. Personalization, location, device, constant testing by Google. We were always just sampling. AI just makes it impossible now to pretend otherwise So let's go to option objection six. AI crawlers behave differently This is the last one. There are far more bots now. There's GPT bot, Claude bot, Perplexity bot, and plenty more. Most of them don't run JavaScript. Some are gathering training data, some are fetching a page live because the user's just asked a question. All this is true, but at the end of the day, every part of it is all about crawlability. This is technical SEO, which just has a longer list of agents when you're doing a technical SEO audit. Now, you don't just care about mainly Googlebot and Bingbot a bit. You now have to care about all these other bots and make decisions on whether you're gonna let them crawl or not. And then if you are gonna let them crawl 'cause you wanna be indexed and made discoverable in AI, then it's just another set of agents to make sure that you are treating properly. So it's still just crawlability. But it does raise a practical problem, which is, most people have no idea what these crawls are doing on their site. So hold that thought 'cause I'm gonna come back to that in a bit.
Now, what I'll concede, I did say I take the other side seriously, so here are the two places where I think they have a point. The first is model memory, and that's when an AI searches sorry, answers without searching the web at all. It's working from what it's learnt in training. There's no crawl, index, and rank loop there that you can influence quickly. Nothing you can c- do this week that is gonna shape how those answers are gonna necessarily change over the next, sh- mid, short to medium term. What shapes those answers is how widely and how consistently you've been talked about over the years, and that's brand building, and it's a slower lever. I'd argue it's the long game of understandability, but I do accept it doesn't map neatly onto anything in the classic SEO toolkit. The second is the label itself. GEO gets attention. It gets budget. It gets the C-level people to care about technical fixes they've ign- ignored for five years. If calling it GEO is what gets your work funded, what gets you sign off, I'm not gonna die on that hill, okay? My objection is narrower than that. It's GEO being sold as a separate practice with a separate team that skips the fundamentals that underpin it. Certain things have changed. The meas- the way we measure things has changed. But underneath, the main pillars that have built SEO over the past 20, 30 plus years all still underpin this
So if the fundamentals are the same, what should you actually do differently on Monday? Three things, and they're all about where you look. One, you need to start tracking topics and prompts, not just keywords. Because of query fan-out, you want to know how often you show up across a whole set of questions, not just where you sit for one phrase. It's that topic coverage and how you come up across a topic is the key thing to be covering. Secondly, you need to check what the AI engines actually say about you across more than one of them and more than once. Just doing one search, one screenshot, that tells you nothing. And thirdly, and this is the one that almost nobody is doing, look at what the AI crawlers are doing on your site. If you think about your current report and you've got Search Console tells you about Googlebot and only Googlebot. Your analytics runs on a script in the browser, and crawlers don't trigger that script. So GPTbot, Clawbot, Perplexity Bot, and the rest are invisible in both. Which means for the very first of those four fundamentals, can they find and fetch your pages? Most businesses can't answer that question
at the moment. They're arguing about geo strategy without knowing whether AI has ever read the page, and this is the gap where Salience comes in. So on salience.com, we read the s- the server and the CDN logs your site already produces. There's no tracking script to add, nothing to change on the front end, but we do show you each crawler request as it happens and what your site sent back. So you c- you can see the pages the AI crawlers are actually reading and which ones they never touch, where they're getting errors, redirects, or blocks. It also checks that a bot claiming to G- to be GPT bot really is, and it separates crawling for training from live fetches for AI search. And that second one matters because a live fetch means someone somewhere just asked a question that your page might have the answer for. It sits alongside your Search Console and analytics. It doesn't replace them, it-- but it covers the part you cannot see.
Speaker 5
So if you really want to know what AI is really up to on your site, then the link is in the description or just go to salience.com.
So wrapping up, GEO, I don't think it's not a new game. It's the same game, but just with a new scoreboard and a slightly wider pitch. You've got to be discoverable, crawlable, indexable, and understandable. If you get those four right, you're doing SEO right, you're doing GEO right, you're doing AEO right. Whatever you call it, you're doing it right. You just need to read the new scoreboard. Don't stop doing the things that put points on it. So thanks for listening. If you disagree or agree, tell me, get in touch. This is a topic I've seen people argue about over and over again, but this is my take on it, and this is where I stand.