SEO Is Not That Hard

Link Building ep 1 : Backlinks - the Good, the Bad & the Ugly

Edd Dawson Season 1 Episode 334

Send us a text

Want search visibility that survives the next update and shows up in AI answers? We dive straight into the real calculus of link building: what still works, what crumbles under scrutiny, and how to build a backlink profile that compounds rather than collapses. Drawing on two decades of building, buying, and selling sites, Ed breaks down backlinks into three buckets—good, bad, and ugly—and explains the risks behind each, from short‑term bumps to long, painful recoveries.

We start with first principles: why links remain a core ranking signal and why AI assistants increasingly rely on citations to choose which sources to show. From there, we revisit the wild‑west years of easy link spam and the moment Penguin flipped the table, turning yesterday’s playbook into a liability. No moralising here—just pragmatic risk management. If you’re considering paid placements, niche edits, or PBNs, you’ll hear the pattern risks that can flag manipulation: lumpy velocity, repeating footprints, irrelevant anchors and networks built on expired domains.

Then we turn to the durable path. Ed outlines what makes a link “good” in practice—editorial, relevant, earned because the page genuinely helps someone else’s audience—and how to create assets that attract those links without cold outreach. Think original data, simple tools, clear frameworks, and opinionated guides packaged for easy citation. You’ll get a blueprint for seeding discovery through newsletters, communities, and journalists so that value finds the people who need it.

If you want rankings that last, less time worrying about link spam updates, and a brand that others cite because it helps their readers, this conversation gives you the strategy and the mindset to get there. Enjoy the episode, then subscribe, share with a friend who obsesses over DR, and leave a quick review to help more people find the show.

SEO Is Not That Hard is hosted by Edd Dawson and brought to you by KeywordsPeopleUse.com

Help feed the algorithm and leave a review at ratethispodcast.com/seo

You can get your free copy of my 101 Quick SEO Tips at: https://seotips.edddawson.com/101-quick-seo-tips

To get a personal no-obligation demo of how KeywordsPeopleUse could help you boost your SEO and get a 7 day FREE trial of our Standard Plan book a demo with me now

See Edd's personal site at edddawson.com

Ask me a question and get on the show Click here to record a question

Find Edd on Linkedin, Bluesky & Twitter

Find KeywordsPeopleUse on Twitter @kwds_ppl_use

"Werq" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

SPEAKER_00:

Hi, Sad Dawson here. Now link building has always been and continues to be a crucial part of the SEO jigsaw that you need to build authority and drive rankings in Google. And with the emergence of AI-based search like ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and Perplexity, the importance of links in getting your site cited in responses means that link building becomes of even greater importance. So I've grouped together all the best episodes of the podcast that touch on link building into a series dedicated to all the money strategies and tactics you can use to get more links to your content. So let's get on to the podcast. Hello and welcome to SEO Is Not That Hard. I'm your host, Ed Dawson, the founder of KeywordspeopleUse.com, the solution to finding the questions people ask online. I'm an affiliate marketer, SEO, and I've been building and monetizing websites for over 20 years. I've built sites from the ground up, bought sites and sold sites in large exits. I'm here to share with you the SEO knowledge, hints and tips I've built up over the years. Today I'm going to talk about backlinks, the good, the bad, and the ugly. If you're a regular listener to the podcast, you'll probably have noticed that I haven't talked much about backlinks previously. Now, backlinks, just brief definition for those that aren't sure what I'm talking about. Anytime that another website links to your website, that's called an external backlink, and that's the back the type of backlink I'm going to talk talk about now. So that's links from other websites to your website. Now, in terms of SEO, these links actually help your SEO. It's part of Google's ranking algorithm, part of the page rank algorithm is taking takes into account how many links and what sort of links come from external sites to your site. In general, the more links you've got, the better. There are nuances, some links are better than others. Some websites give more power when they link to you than smaller websites. There's things like relevance and the anchor text, all matter. The more relevant an anchor text is, the more it'll help you rank for that similar terms to that. But I'm not going to go into huge details on those this time around. But just wanted to say, yeah, backlinks from external websites to your website do count for SEO, and it is an important thing. Now, taking this on board, knowing that backlinks are quite important for SEO, you could be tempted to say, Well, let's forget about everything else, let's just go and get as many backlinks as we can possibly get and get them linking to our website, and that will help us rank. We won't need to do anything else. Now, again, that is generally 15 years ago, that was quite accepted. That's what most people did, and I did it myself. If you've listened to um some of the podcasts where I talk about the story of broadband.co and how we got hit by penalties. I talk about then when yeah, we just went nuts. We would buy, we paid people to link to us, we did um link spam from um uh forums where we just get people to put forum posts in for us and photo posts and comment posts and and all sorts of links, and there's all sorts of really low-quality links. And back then, it didn't harm you to do that. Google made noises that didn't want people to do this because they realized that people just gaining backlinks by any means possible was potentially polluting their algorithm and getting people to rank where they weren't necessarily the best site, they just had the most links, and everybody did it. But then along came Penguin, the Penguin algorithm, and that penalised lots of sites that were buying uh and creating poor quality links. And ever since um we got hit by Penguin really badly, and I've talked about this in other podcast episodes, so I'd say go and listen to them for the full story. I made a conscious decision that I wasn't doing that again because we got hit so hard and the recovery took so long and such a risk. For me, the risk-reward ratio wasn't there. Now, before we go any further, I just want to say that I'm not puritanical about how people run their websites and the choices that they they make. I've got no problem if people want to buy and sell links. I don't judge people for buying and selling links, that's completely up to them. It's not illegal. Google's terms of services are not the law. If you break them, then you know there is no, as far as I'm concerned, there's no moral or legal legal issue with that. Um, and some people quite happily do it, and I think it's fair enough as long as everybody on both sides of the equation understands the risks and potential rewards from it. So I'm not going to be sitting here from a judgy point of view, I'm literally just saying what my point of view is and the reasons why I make the choices that I do now when it comes to link building. Okay, so now let's start with the good. So the good backlinks are the ones which you naturally receive, these are ones where you don't make any solicitation, you don't make any payment, no persuasion. These are just the kind of backlinks that people find your site, discover your site, and find it valuable enough that they will link to it from their website. It may be because you are sharing some data or providing a tool or something that's useful for that person and for their audience. Now, these links are great because A, it's not against Google's terms of service, b, they don't cost anything, C, they tend to stand there for a long time. The longevity of those links is good. There's there's no reason for people to go and take them away. So these are the gold standard, and that's what I now aim for with any site I produce. Um, if you go and look at say the bat link profile of keywords people use, um you know we've done no link building at all for that site. It we just built a good product and a good site, and it's naturally received links. So if you want to see an org a truly organic um backlink profile, go and look at keywords people use is batlink profile in a tool like AHREFs or something like that, and that's what to aim for. And there's no risk in that backlink profile. I don't lose sleep worrying. Am I ever going to get caught out for that, or is there any are they gonna cause me any issues? Because it's just all completely natural. So that's that's that's the good links, that's the gold standard, they're the very best. That's what I call good, and that's what I always aim for myself. Okay, so moving on, what's the bad? Well, maybe bad's a bit too strong because they maybe the more dodgy, the iffy links. Now, these are the ones where they look like they are a natural link, um, but you have made a deal with someone, you've paid them to link to you. If we look at Google's spam guidelines, which I'll link to um in the show notes, these are the ones within those guidelines where you know it's going to be hard when you're just looking at the page to determine that that those links have been put there um by being paid for. So things like exchanging money for links or posts that contain links, exchanging goods or services for links, sending someone a product in exchange for them, writing about it and including a link. Um, now yeah, so that these are these are the kind of the dodgy ones. Now, okay, it's hard to tell necessarily that they've been placed um with payment, but I wouldn't be surprised if Google um can sort of compare bat link profiles between sites which where it doesn't think this is happening and ones where it is happening, and it's it's a thing like the type of the number and type of links that a site attracts. If if it's lumpy, if you're all of a sudden um getting links from particular types of sites that you weren't before and it's just coming in little chunks regularly, then there's little patterns that where AI in the future, if it's not doing it now, might be able to determine that uh sort of the growth of a link profile is not necessarily natural. So whether they can do that at the moment or not is a different matter. That's maybe a future risk. Um, but it's those are the kind of the links where you have to tread carefully, I'd say, if you're gonna do it. Um, and you know they are the risk is lower, but I think there's always going to be a risk. So then on to the ugly. What are the ugly backlinks? Now, these are the ones that you know you could look at a page, see a backlink on it, and go, hang on, that's not there naturally. Um, these are things like um footer links, um, sort of so bulk footer links in the in the bottom of a page where it's linking off to unrelated sites with unrelated anchor texts. You can see that someone who's controlling this site is just selling that that footer text. Um, it can be things like putting spam into comments, spam into forums, um, with links in, um, and it can be, I think, things niche edits is one that I always worry about. That's where people pay to have a bat link inserted in an older article. Um, and things like that can possibly done badly, can look unnatural. Another one would be um private blog networks. Um, now a private blog network done well and controlled could potentially drop into the bad rather than ugly category. Um, but a lot of them that I've seen are not done like that, they're just you know expired domains with pages full of unrelated posts, stuffed full of um bat links, um, and it's just people who are controlling those um those networks, trying to make as much money as possible by selling links on them. Um and it's those where you know in the short run they might work for you, but in the longer run, those are the ones that could couldn't come back to bite you in the long run. Um, and trust me, it is so much harder clearing up a link spam mess than just never doing it in the first place. Um, so yeah, see those ugly ones are the ones that are really going to cause you issues, and Google do from time to time run link spam updates where they will actually go around and penalize sites that they think are doing um sort of engaging in dodgy link practices. So that's the three types the good, the bad, the ugly. Now, just to go back to my previous point, I do not judge people who use any of these different tactics. It is open for everyone to do what they want, there's no laws broken, I'm not the moral police, it's fine. As I say, I've done these some of these things in the past, and they worked until they didn't. And again, I think if you went and did it now, if you if you did some of the uh more uh bad and ugly ones, then yeah, they they may work for a period, and how long that period is, it could be a short time, could be a long time. But are they likely to work forever? Probably not. And when the time comes, you gotta you've got to clear it up, you just got to be accept that risk. And if you're willing to upset that accept that risk and and take it as take it for what it is for as long as you can, then fine. But if you um I subscribe to a different philosophy now because of the being you know once bit and twice shy. My philosophy now is very much create something great and make sure that then you concentrate on on people linking to you naturally as your as your linking strategy. I will do further episodes about the kind of content uh that actually will attract links naturally. Um, it's it's harder to do, it's that easy to put up a website and just put anything on it. It's harder to make a website which is actually linkable um by people naturally. Um, but there are there are patterns there and there's things that you can do, and I'll talk about that in a future episode. Thanks for listening, I really appreciate it. Please subscribe and share, it really helps. SGO is not the hard is brought to you by KeywordspeopletoUse.com, the solution to finding the questions people ask online. See where thousands of people use us every day. Try it today for free at Keywordspeopletouse.com. If you want to get in touch or have any questions, I'd love to hear from you. I'm at channel 5 on Twitter. Or you can email me at podcast at KewidgePooptoUse.com. Bye for now and see you in the next episode of SEO It's Not That Hard.